October 26, 2021
Book Reviews

Neighbors, by Jan T. Gross

Reviewed by Marek Jan Chodakiewicz

When faced with serious criticism of his book, Gross and his supporters resorted to the argument that the book’s main contribution lay in its “shock value.” The readers should disregard the (numerous) shortcomings, they asserted. What mattered was the therapeutic shock capable of reshaping the Poles’ self-image and, by extension, their identity. In the enclosed essay, Prof. Chodakiewicz addresses the grave flaws of the author’s consequentialist, purely agenda-driven approach.

Research before Conclusion: The Problems of Shock Therapy in Jedwabne

https://www.iwp.edu/wp-content/uploads/2002/01/MJ-Chodakiewicz-Shock-Therapy-Jedwabne-Feb-2001.pdf

Related posts

Powrot do Jedwabnego, by Wojciech Sumlinski. 2019

Polonia

Poland Under the Boot of Tsarist Russia: A Firsthand Account

Polonia

Collaboration by ALL Nations

Polonia

Gates of Tears, by David Silberklang. 2014

Polonia

Salomon Morel: An Unpunished, Israeli-Sheltered Communist Criminal

Polonia

American Eyewitness German-Occupied Poland. No Dichotomy: Poles and Jews. Myths on Looting, Black Market, Blue Police, Debunked

Polonia

Leave a Comment

* By using this form you agree with the storage and handling of your data by this website.