June 21, 2024
Germany and Poland

Hitler’s Pope? Not So Fast

by Marek Jan Chodakiewicz
March 23, 2020

Professor Henry Kamen of Oxford was one of the fiercest detractors of the Supreme Sacred Congregation of the Roman and Universal Inquisition (currently known as the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith). Then Pope John Paul II allowed him into the Secret Vatican Archives which led to the publication of The Spanish Inquisition: A Historical Revision (New Haven, CT, and London: Yale University Press, 1998). Neither Hillaire Belloc nor William Thomas Walsh, fine Catholic apologists, ever managed to destroy la leyenda negra of the Inquisition to the extent that this Jewish scholar has. It has not disappeared as a bogeyman from popular culture, but certainly no self-respecting historian countenances the nonsense that used to pass for “knowledge” about the Inquisition.

Is this what we can expect from the latest round of the opening of the Vatican archives? Perhaps. In this instance, however, we are no longer battling the propaganda of the Protestant Reformation over issues that most of our secularized world finds rather irrelevant. Rather, we are up against an insidious, long-lasting effort to make the Catholic Church co-responsible for what Western public opinion holds as the most heinous crime in history: the Holocaust. It was Nazi Germany’s comprehensive and unprecedented project to exterminate every Jewish man, woman, and child in Europe, resulting in about six million deaths. Revisionist historians, playwrights, and pundits have long tried, if not to assign blame, then at least a degree of responsibility to Catholicism as an “ideology” and Pope Pius XII as the pontiff in charge. For some, he was simply “Hitler’s Pope.”

But was he? Of course not. Former Romanian communist secret police Securitate General Ion Pacepa, upon his defection, revealed that the campaign against Rome was initially engineered by Moscow.

Read more at Crisis Magazine:

Related posts

Might Makes Right. Germany Dutifully Pays the Jews and Screws Poland. And This Is All Right!


German Reparations to Poland: 1953 Soviet-Era Words a Long-Term German Excuse for Refusal


Shifting the Blame for the Holocaust Away From Germany and On To Other European Nations


The Nazi German Genocide of Poles in the Light of the Nuremberg Trials


Jews Get Restitution While Non-Jewish Victims of the Nazis Usually Do Not


WWII Reparations: A view from Germany


Leave a Comment

* By using this form you agree with the storage and handling of your data by this website.