March 1, 2024
Book Reviews Polish/Jewish Relations Recommended Books

Collaboration Was By ALL Nations: Poles Were Not a “Bad” People

Poland’s Holocaust

Ethnic Strife, Collaboration with Occupying Forces and Genocide in the Second Republic, 1918-1947

By Tadeusz Piotrowski. 1997 

Reviewed by Jan Peczkis

This book, now written over twenty years ago, uses the term Holocaust not only to refer to the Jews, but also to all the victims of the Nazis AND the victims of Soviet Communism. (Nowadays, the term Holocaust has been largely monopolized by the Jews. For this reason, the term Polocaust can be used to refer to the Nazi German genocide of ethnic Poles.)

COLLABORATION WITH THE NAZIS. ZYDOKOMUNA DENIALISM REJECTED

This book has separate chapters on the collaboration of various nationalities (including Jews) with both the Soviets and the Nazis. In particular, Piotrowski shows how some Polish Jews greeted the invading Germans (p. 66). He then details the many forms of Jewish Nazi collaboration. (pp. 66-75). He also refutes the argument that the prewar Zydokomuna had been marginal (p. 36) and goes into detail about Jewish-Soviet collaboration in 1939 (pp. 49-on) and again in 1944 (pp. 58-on).

Piotrowski also has a section on Polish collaboration. This adds refutation to the canard that Poles are “too nationalistic” to entertain notions of Poles as other than heroes. This is the bogeyman of “Poland’s heroic narrative”.

THE MORE THINGS CHANGE, THE MORE THEY REMAIN THE SAME

Various Polonophobic Holocaust accusations are addressed and answered by author and scholar Tadeusz Piotrowski. The informed reader may be struck by the fact that, decades later, much the same accusations keep coming up over and over again.

Related posts

Why Ukrainians are angrier at Poles than they are at Russians; Machiavelli has an explanation

Polonia

Statement on the crimes committed by the German Reich in occupied Poland and on the false information appearing in public

Polonia

Germans did punish the Poles, and more severely than they punished the Jews. And what is worse than the death penalty? The death of the family

Polonia

Between Katyn and Auschwitz, by M. B. Szonert

Polonia

Jews Make Common Cause With the Nazis When They Blame Poles

Polonia

Andrew Kornbluth’s Bizarre Claims of an “Anti-Jewish” Postwar Communist Judiciary

Polonia

Leave a Comment

* By using this form you agree with the storage and handling of your data by this website.